Coins Are a Curious Thing

Posted on 2/21/2019

Scribe to the tribe: Indians make sense.

As often happens during the winter season, I find myself at the mercy of the elements. This past weekend was one of those occasions: moderate snowfall lingering all day, howling winds and frigid temps. Old Man Winter’s wrath allotted me time to stay inside my warm abode, and with my internet down, I decided to pull out some old numismatic volumes, catalogs, sundry magazines and related literature.

After riffling through a few old newsletters and fixed-price lists, I found myself waxing nostalgic about coins, and just why they have been an integral part of my life: I calculate now that I’ve been a "coindexter" for about 87% of my existence and counting (but who’s counting!)

The great collector

I fondly recall, after intellectually devouring my first Red Book from cover to cover around this time of year in 1965, that I soon found myself fantasizing about these curious metal discs. I dreamt about how I would travel the world and locate lost and forgotten caches of rarities. Through sleuthing, hobnobbing and careful research, I would become the Great Collector! As my network of notable numismatic brethren grew, fame and fortune would follow, as I would eventually secure a coin in every grade listed in the Red Book!

Well, of course, this didn’t quite happen. But I am thrilled to be able to research, catalog and report on the subject that I enjoy and care about so much. Coins have always been a curious thing: They are not just money, but living bits of history circulating through the hands of untold humanity.

For the new or aspiring collector who asks what is so fascinating about this hobby, one of my responses is akin to the proverbial snowflakes that have been chasing me around here: No two coins are exactly alike. Color, strike, die varieties, etc. make each coin unique. Aside from that, it is a great, enjoyable and rewarding quest.

So whether you’re building an individual type set, or your goal is a complete collection by date and mintmark, a lifetime of enjoyment will be yours.

Scribe to the tribe

1857 Flying Eagle Cent
Click images to enlarge.

For the collector just getting acquainted with the hobby, Indian Cents are a great series to assemble. All told, these wildly popular coins enjoyed a 50-year run! Replacing the massive, large cents in 1857, were the famous and short-lived Flying Eagle Cents, which were produced on a much smaller planchet and composed of a new copper-nickel composition, giving them a slightly white look.

1859 Indian Head Cent
Click images to enlarge.

Then, commencing in 1859, The Indian Head Cent (also in copper-nickel) made its first appearance. Through much of the Civil War years, the composition remained the same until 1864, when, in addition to the copper-nickel variety, the familiar bronze issues were introduced. Until 1909, the coin design and composition remained the same.

Affordable and historic

The copper-nickel issues (1859-1864) are all highly affordable in high-grade circ through average Mint State. And aside from the 1877 and 1909-S, the rest of the series poses no real financial stress to acquire in circulated grades, and even mint state. Be sure to visit the NGC Price Guide for guidance and to help formulate budgeting and strategy!

Pick a color

1909 Indian Head Cent
Click images to enlarge.

For my fellow coindexter looking to take the plunge, perhaps an Indian Head Cent from the last year of that series, 1909, will serve as an excellent first acquisition. The coin may be a worn but problem-free VG grade, and aside from the design detail, the coloring may be tan, woodgrain, chocolate or even charcoal in appearance.

These fabulous bronze coins in Mint State can be a glossy brown, blonde, Red and Brown, brick red, pumpkin orange, golden and a plethora of patination in between. The individual character of these coins is one of the reasons that Indian Cents have one of the most ardent followings.

For the beginner, a great entry point would be to assemble coins from, say, 1888 to the end of the series. With the exception of the 1908-S and 1909-S, this tribe can be located and bought with great ease: Generally for $5 or less in Very Fine and better, to under $50 for most mint state (MS 60-62) brown and even red and brown designated coins.

To get a jump-start on your quest, take a look at this diverse tribe: A handful of delightful and affordable Indian Cents currently up for bid at Great Collections & David Lawrence Rare Coin online auctions.

1907 Indian Head Cent
Click images to enlarge.

This 1907 Indian Head Cent, graded NGC AU 58 BN is just a lovely glossy median brown coin on the cusp of full Mint State! A common and very affordable coin within the series, yet so attractive!

1880 Indian Head Cent
Click images to enlarge.

Here is an 1880 Indian Head Cent, graded NGC MS 65 RB. This is a better late date in high grade. This coin is so visually compelling. Red, mauve, icy blue race over the sharply struck obverse! A mere 17 coins grade numerically higher within the RB designation.

1899 Indian Head 1 Cent
Click images to enlarge.

This 1899 Indian Head 1 Cent, graded NGC MS 65 RB, is a vibrant and lustrous red and brown example from the last coin of the 1800s! A slightly better date possessing great eye appeal!

1901 Indian Head Cent
Click images to enlarge.

Here is another delightful virtual Mint State coin: This 1901 Indian Head Cent,graded NGC AU 58 BN. Just look at the robust red and orange showcasing the design elements though a common coin; she is truly special.

1862 Indian Head Cent
Click images to enlarge.

Here is a nicely contrasted “white cent” struck during the early part of the Civil War. This 1862 Indian Head Cent, graded NGC XF 45, is a great type coin of the copper-nickel variety Indian, and also a historic relic of the War Between the States.

Until next time, happy collecting!

Jim Bisognani is an NGC Price Guide Analyst, having previously served for many years as an analyst and writer for another major price guide. He has written extensively on US coin market trends and values.

Want to see more articles like this? Subscribe to the free NGC Weekly Market Report.

Stay Informed

Want news like this delivered to your inbox once a month? Subscribe to the free NGC eNewsletter today!


You've been subscribed to the NGC eNewsletter.

Unable to subscribe to our eNewsletter. Please try again later.

Articles List

Add Coin

Join NGC for free to add coins, track your collection and participate in the NGC Registry. Learn more >

Join NGC

Already a member? Sign In
Add to NGC Coin Registry Example
The NGC Registry is not endorsed by or associated with PCGS or CAC. PCGS is a registered trademark of Collectors Universe, Inc. CAC is a trademark of Certified Acceptance Corporation.