Guess the Grade....................

[BAJJERFAN]

that PCGS gave to this 1923-S Walker.

 

 

 

[BillJones]

EF-40, although I might be inclided call it a VF-35 if I were grading it.

 

If they called it EF-45 or most especially AU-50, it is "grade - flation."

[MarkFeld]

45

[morganguru]

I'll wager EF40, nice even wear IMO.

[billet7-migration]

40 straight up.

[BAJJERFAN]

40 it is.

[KeyMan64]

40

[FishyOne]

40 it is.

 

Fair and honest grade for that one.

[Dillon Kraft]

Guesses are more consistent this time.

[BAJJERFAN]

Guesses are more consistent this time.

 

They are!

[physics-fan3.14]

Guesses are more consistent this time.

 

They are!

 

Circulated coins are, generally speaking, much easier to grade consistently.

[Raisethis2]

VF 40

[Treashunt]

agreed: 40

[BAJJERFAN]

The guesses weren't quite as consistent ATS.

[coinman1794]

I'm probably late coming to this thread, but I would guess XF45. Early 1920s Walkers are graded differently than the later ones. This piece has minimal wear and what appears to be moderate luster in the fields.

[Kurtdog]

She looks cleaned. Technically, she barely squeaks into EF.