Please critique this Morgan

[SWNGC]

 

Thanks

[SWNGC]

2nd image of reverse

[Coindude]

65+ but I'll have to say only PL, seems to be a bit hazy, but maybe that's just in the pictures. The words seem to come out pretty clear in the reflection but I'm still gonna have to call it PL.

[gbsten]

Looks like some chatter in front of the eyes that the lighting/angle isn't bringing out. At least 1 cheek hit. Reverse typical. Hard to tell, probably at least SPL, but need to get the coin off the surface to make a decent call. I'll go with MS64PL.

[michael]

impossible to tell for sure from the photo

 

but

i can say

 

 

nice choice unc prooflike

[SWNGC]

Close up provided

 

-Obv, Light lustre impairment runs from base of L to just out from brow -

-Obv, Small hit on chin can be seen in original photos, very, very slight hit below right side of eye on cheek

-Remainder of Obv is well represented in photo and I believe easily PL, very clean, sparse but even cloud/haze kills dmpl - LOOK AT THE STRENGTH OF STRIKE IN HAIR/EAR/ETC

-Rev is very, very near DMPL and as clean as I've ever seen.

 

Thanks in advance for opinions...

[michael]

i still think after the new close-up

 

choice unc. and prooflike

 

a good coin with definately above average eye appeal

[James_OldeTowne]

Call me crazy, but it looks SPL (semi-prooflike) to me, although MS-65 seems realistic.

[L1ncolnF4n]

Call me crazy, but it looks SPL (semi-prooflike) to me, although MS-65 seems realistic.

 

What he said. Not quite enough contrast in the straight on shots as I'd expect in a PL, let alone a DMPL. It is unquestionably semi-PL and may get a PL, but without it in hand I wouldn't say that for sure. 65 seems about right, maybe 64 if your comments in the second post are readily visible in hand.

[michael]

when i saw the coin tilted in the newspaper and it had that much pl surfaces i thought pl as the other photos i think mask the true pl surfaces and i bet in hand it is pl

 

thsi was my conclusion based on that tilted photo as again the head on photos i think mask the true pl

 

but...........................

 

 

i cant see it in hand so i cant say for sure

[SWNGC]

In "hand"

[Coindude]

I think maybe the problem with this coin is it might be over dipped and that might be what's causing the field reflectivity to be subdued. Just a thought. Don't kill the messenger!

[Ahab]

MS66 PL

[gold_fever-migration]

GLOVES dang it!

;-)