Augustus

  • entries
    45
  • comments
    33
  • views
    1,824

Is this a coin or a medal?

1 1
Augustus 70

308 views

A quick question for the community.  Would you consider the Royal Dutch Mint’s restrikes of the silver daalders to be coins or medals.  They bear a date and are struck by the Nederlandse Munt, and are commemoratives of the original daalders/ducat/ducaton.  NGC appears to recognize it as a ‘daalder’ or ‘dollar’ coin, but it doesn’t have an assigned Euro denomination.  So is it a medal then?   Thanks in advance.

F2BD3331-6BF0-42E3-9C8E-E04A365786ED.png

1 1


6 Comments


Recommended Comments

You probably don't want to hear my opinion because I don't consider any mint issue that wasn't intended for actual circulation (or proof strike made during the production of a coin intended for circulation) to be a coin.  Restrikes, replicas and non-circulating commemoratives all fall into the non-coin category for me.  There are, of course, official definitions for coins but I think these just serve the mints that make money by repackaging bullion for collectors and the TPGs that make money grading these things.

I don't collect medals but I imagine they have a definition that doesn't automatically include non-coins.  That place in-between coins and medals I just call "tokens".

 

Share this comment


Link to comment

I'm sorry if my post seems too critical.  I own some modern commemoratives too and realize that it's a popular collecting area.  Let me just close by saying that actual daalders from the 16th and 17th centuries are not difficult to find.

Share this comment


Link to comment

I  would actually not even consider this a coin or a medal.  It is simply a 2 ounce bullion piece with an attractive retro design.  As JGENN stated, actual Lion Dollars are plentiful, and have historic and monetary integrity. 

Share this comment


Link to comment

The label states exactly what it is.  It's a Piefort!  Or more correctly, it's a Piedfort.

A good description of what a peidfort is can be found here: Piedfort Coins - Heavyweight Coin Collecting.

Piedforts are essentially an extra thick example (generally twice as thick) of a coin intended for circulation.  Much like the U.S. Silver Eagle silver bullion coin, the Royal Dutch mint also issues a once ounce silver bullion coin utilizing the same design found on this piedfort. Although never struck, the U.S. equivalent would be a 2 oz. U.S. Silver Eagle piedfort.

It doesn't call my name, but it is a piedfort (or piefort if you prefer the misspelling) of an official Royal Dutch mint issued one oz. silver bullion coin.

Share this comment


Link to comment

It is simply a two ounce piece of bullion. That's all I would say. So weigh it and get The price of silver there your price. 

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now