Heritage Auctions: 1833 $5 Large Date Coin, PR 61 NGC
Posted on 10/16/2012
[Dallas, TX] –
The census of 1833 proof half eagles is hardly complicated, as only three or four are known, one in the Smithsonian Institution, and another in a tightly held private collection. Nothing is known of the third piece in the roster; it is an example graded PR 63 by NGC, but its whereabouts are unknown to the collecting public. In our Dallas Signature Auction, we are offering the only example that will likely be available to collectors at any time in the foreseeable future. At Proof-61, it is also a lower grade than the others, meaning it is more affordable, relatively speaking.
The three traced proofs are all from the BD-1 or Large Date die pair, with no proofs known from the Small Date obverse die. There are also a couple of other pieces that have been called proof in the past, but are now considered prooflike business strikes. Dannreuther mentions the Smithsonian piece in his reference, but fails to mention either of the other two specimens.
This early die state proof shows no signs of clash marks or cracks, with slight evidence of lapping, as certain details are diminished. The reverse die was used with two 1832-dated obverse dies, and with two 1833-dated obverse dies. Examination of the large plates in John Dannreuther's Early U.S. Gold Coin Varieties, A Study of Die States, 1795-1834, clearly shows the progression of die lapping, especially at the eagle's talon that hangs down from the upper leaf pair.
The deeply mirrored fields of this green-gold proof surround satin devices, imparting a trace of cameo contrast. Proof finish appears in the recesses of the design, such as the letters of LIBERTY and the spaces between shield stripes. The fields are lightly hairlined with other minor surface marks expected for the grade. A hint of striking softness is noted at the usual spots, especially among the wing feathers just left of the shield. When it was offered 14 years ago, this piece was conservatively graded PR 58 NGC, and that old grading event still appears in the NGC Census Report.
The thoughts and opinions in the piece are those of their author and are not necessarily the thoughts of the Certified Collectibles Group.