Grading mistake?

[jcort]

Is this coin overgraded or is it a mint error that wasn’t labeled as such? Grade is MS68. #2066226-014 huge scratch on reverse

[Matt G]

Thank you for your post. The markings on the coin were taken into consideration at the time of grading. If you would like the coin to be evaluated again please submit as an appearance review and our graders will look at it again. Please email me directly for instructions on this process. Thank you

mgens@ngccoin.com

[jcort]

Hi Matt , thank you for the reply. 

If they were taken into consideration, doesn’t that mean once submitted again it would get the same grade?

 

[jcort]

This coin IMO should be ms68 mint error or unc details scratched.

[Matt G]

Each coin is evaluated by multiple experts who reach a consensus on the grade. While this is a very consistent process, it is still an opinionated service, therefore there is a slight chance that it could change. The coin was not originally submitted for the mint error process therefore it was graded as is. If you submit again you can request for it to be examined as a mint error to see if this designation can be attributed.