Grading Contest

[RareSov]

63

64

64

64

65

[gbsten]

Hint: thatothercoinguy has made the best assessment so far!

[RareSov]

64

64

65

63

64

[fishfinder]

64

64

64

62

66

[HiHoAudio]

Hint: thatothercoinguy has made the best assessment so far!

 

Beginners luck or a numismatic natural? :laugh:

[Schatzy]

This was my first guess

1. MS64

2. MS64

3. MS63

4. MS63

5. MS65

 

So how about my second guess

1. MS64

2. MS64

3. MS63

4. MS64

5. MS65

[mtnstyne]

64

63

64

64

65

[RareSov]

64

64

65

64

63

[rrantique]

MS 64

MS 63

MS 64

MS 64

MS 65 (thumbs u

[Schatzy]

So how about my second guess

1. MS64

2. MS64

3. MS63

4. MS64

5. MS65

MS 64

MS 64

MS 63

MS 64

MS 65 (thumbs u

 

Copy Cat!!

[rrantique]

So how about my second guess

1. MS64

2. MS64

3. MS63

4. MS64

5. MS65

MS 64

MS 64

MS 63

MS 64

MS 65 (thumbs u

 

Copy Cat!!

 

Oops Great minds think alike.

[relicsncoins]

I'll go;

63

62

64

62

64

[fishfinder]

62

64

64

64

66

[RareSov]

63

65

64

64

64

[gbsten]

Hint: Lowest graded coin is #4.

[physics-fan3.14]

So, lets think through this logically. We know the total is 320, and one is higher and one is lower than the rest. That means there are 3 64's, 1 63, and 1 65. We further know that #4 is the 63, and have unsuccessfully tried 64-64-64-63-65 and 64-64-65-63-64. That means either the first or second coin is the 65. I'll take a 50-50 shot and say its the first one, whoever posts next can take the remaining possible answer, and one of the two of us must be right.

 

65

64

64

63

64

[Schatzy]

64

65

64

63

64

[Coindude]

64

64

64

63

65

[RareSov]

65

63

64

64

64

 

*gives up*

[rrantique]

64

64

64

63

65

 

[fishfinder]

64

64

64

62

66

 

one is higher and one is lower than the rest, they add to 320, and the 4th is the lowest

[physics-fan3.14]

64

64

64

63

65

 

 

already been guessed and is wrong

 

64

64

64

62

66

 

one is higher and one is lower than the rest, they add to 320, and the 4th is the lowest

 

doesn't fit with clue: one person has correct grades but wrong order

[gbsten]

Schatzy is the winner!!!!! I will post full pics, short of time now.

[gbsten]

Nice analysis Physics-Fan!

[gbsten]

PM me your address and I will get your prize in the mail. Nothing too special, but I would put it at least PF-65. I have posted the full pics for everyone. Sorry, some of the pics weren't that good, but that's what I got for my $3 per coin fee from NGC! These pics may not be in the same order.

[rrantique]

Way to go Jaime (thumbs u

[fishfinder]

Congratulations Schatzy!

[mtnstyne]

congrats, I have to work on my grading skills...

[RareSov]

Not to complain about winning, but wasn't my guess just before the one you said is closest, closer ?

 

Congrats to Schatzy !

[thatothercoinguy-migration]

Hint: thatothercoinguy has made the best assessment so far!

 

Beginners luck or a numismatic natural? :laugh:

 

Whoa I was that close?!

I relied heavily on the hints, and I graded the coins relative to one another.

 

Also congrats Schatzy!