Grading Contest

[gbsten]

We all know how subjective grading can be so I've come up with a little competition. I recently had five GSA '85-CC Morgans graded at NGC. The first person that can correctly assign the grades given each will win a proof Jefferson (1964). In order to make the contest fair only one guess every 24 hours per person. I am only showing obverses as the reverses are all about the same. I may add hints if needed. Images provided by NGC.

[Schatzy]

1. MS64

2. MS64

3. MS63

4. MS63

5. MS65

[James_OldeTowne]

62,62,63,62,64 will be my only guesses!

 

(Can't judge proof-like potential from these images.)

[BillJones]

MS-62

MS-61

MS-64

MS-61

MS-62

 

The pictures are a bit small, and you are not showing us the reverses.

[bsshog40]

I agree the images are a bit small. I'll just shoot out what I can.

MS62

MS62

MS63

MS62

MS64

[mtnstyne]

1.MS64

2.MS63

3.MS63

4.MS62

5.MS65

 

regardless of how they came back, nice coins

[HiHoAudio]

1. MS62

2. MS62

3. MS63

4. MS61

5. MS64

 

Prices on these seem to be going up lately.

[RareSov]

MS62

MS62

MS63

MS63

MS64

 

[rrantique]

MS63

MS63

MS63

MS63

MS65

[ritter]

1-62 2-63 3-62 4-62 5-64

[Coindude]

63

65

64

64

66

 

I think that last one is pretty sweet!

[gbsten]

Hint: One coin is graded lower than the rest and one coin is graded higher than the rest.

[physics-fan3.14]

63

64

65

64

64

[gbsten]

More pics...same order.

[SWNGC]

62

63

64

63

63

 

[RareSov]

62

63

64

63

63

 

Ahh damn you beat me to it.. do I get another go ?

[gbsten]

Hint: One person has the correct grades, but in the wrong order.

[Jim Beam]

1) 63

2) 64

3) 64

4) 64

5) 65

[RareSov]

63

62

64

63

63

[ritter]

63-62-63-63-64

[mtnstyne]

62

63

63

63

64

[bgraphics-migration]

63

63

63

62

64

[gbsten]

Hint: Grading total of coins is 320 points.

[physics-fan3.14]

63

64

64

65

64

[Jim Beam]

1) 63

2) 64

3) 64

4) 64

5) 65

 

[Coindude]

63

63

64

64

66

[RareSov]

64

63

65

64

64

[Coindude]

how bout all 64's!

[thatothercoinguy-migration]

Well I'm new to coin collecting and to this forum but I'll give it a shot

 

64

64

64

63

65

 

[MercuryMan]

64

64

63

63

65