Toot, Toot -- I really don't like to blow my own horn

1 1
jgenn

418 views

First off, congratulations to all the registry participants and the winners of the 2019 registry awards.  As for me, I won a Classic Set award for my Mexico City 8 reales Pillar Dollars of Charles III (1760-1771).  This is my third major award and I had never posted about them in the past, but for this one I will make an exception.  I want to highlight the wonderfully broad approach that the NGC judges have chosen in selecting sets for their awards.  I haven't yet browsed through all of the other winning sets but I'm sure that mine is more of an outlier than most.  To start with, the advertised criteria for Classic Sets is "US or World Sets, 1792-1964" so my set has somehow slipped through the time-frame constraint.  But the point I want to emphasize is that, using my set as an example, you don't necessarily need the highest grade coins to be considered for an award.  I built much of this set from raw examples -- and most of my coins fall in the XF range!  

Now, I know that many collectors that use the NGC journals or forums are not keen on registry participation for all of the valid reasons that you've posted but maybe some of you might reconsider your opinions.  I believe there are many magnificent collections out there that are just waiting to be recognized.

Here is, perhaps, my least impressive coin from my set, grade-wise. VF details, but still a quite scarce variety.

~jack

1763_Mo_MM_8R.jpg

1 1


8 Comments


Recommended Comments

12 hours ago, Six Mile Rick said:

Congrats Todd!!

Congratulations Jack and Rick on your award winning sets. They are both worthy of recognition!

Share this comment


Link to comment

Congrats on another well-deserved win. :)

i didn't realize they advertised a cut-off on the date range for classic sets on the long end but I guess they have to to delineate them from ancients. But I'd say your set is easily more classic than ancient - 30-40 years in dates aside.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now