New NGC US Auction Central Search View the NGC Auction Central Page for Buffalo Five Cents (1913-1938)

Top 10 Certified Coin Auction Prices

Many of the world's most valuable coins have been graded and certified and have set numerous auction records. Below is a list of the top 10 auction prices realized for certified coins for a particular series.

View The Top 10 Auctions By Country
Series

Buffalo Five Cents


Rank
Service
Price
Coin
Grade
Auction House
Date
1 PCGS $264,500.00 1918/7 D 5C MS MS 65 Heritage Auctions1/6/2010
1 PCGS $264,500.00 1916 DOUBLED DIE OBV 5C MS MS 64 Heritage Auctions9/21/2005
3 PCGS $258,500.00 1918/7 D 5C MS MS 65 Heritage Auctions8/10/2013
4 PCGS $253,000.00 1918/7 D 5C MS MS 65 Heritage Auctions4/28/2009
5 PCGS $195,500.00 1916 DOUBLED DIE OBV 5C MS MS 64 Heritage Auctions1/7/2009
5 PCGS $195,500.00 1918/7 D 5C MS MS 65 Stack's Bowers10/17/2012
7 PCGS $184,000.00 1916 DOUBLED DIE OBV 5C MS MS 64 Heritage Auctions4/28/2009
8 NGC $172,500.00 1916 DOUBLED DIE OBV 5C MS MS 64 Heritage Auctions1/8/2012
9 PCGS $163,300.00 1916 DOUBLED DIE OBV 5C MS MS 62 Goldberg9/26/2007
10 PCGS $161,000.00 1918/7 D 5C MS MS 64 Heritage Auctions6/5/2011

View the NGC Auction Central Page for Buffalo Five Cents (1913-1938)

NGC Auction Central Disclaimer